
In short: The Defense of Marriage Act, signed on 21 September 1996, defined marriage for all federal purposes as between a man and a woman and let states refuse to recognise same-sex marriages from elsewhere. For 17 years it created a patchwork: couples could have a marriage, civil union or domestic partnership under state law but no federal recognition. The Supreme Court struck down the federal definition in United States v. Windsor on 26 June 2013, required marriage equality nationwide in Obergefell v. Hodges on 26 June 2015, and Congress repealed DOMA with the Respect for Marriage Act on 13 December 2022.
Many of the posts on the original version of this site dealt with life under DOMA: a June 2009 letter to the president about a federal brief defending the law, the fight over partner benefits in the health care bill, Wisconsin’s new domestic partner registry, civil unions in Illinois and Hawaii. This article explains the law, the state patchwork it created, and how it came to an end.

Why DOMA was passed
The trigger was Hawaii. In 1993, in Baehr v. Lewin, the Hawaii Supreme Court held that refusing marriage licences to same-sex couples was sex discrimination that the state would have to justify. Opponents feared that couples would marry in Hawaii and demand recognition at home.
Congress responded with DOMA in 1996. It passed the House 342 to 67 and the Senate 85 to 14, and President Clinton signed it on 21 September 1996. Britannica summarises its two key sections.
- Section 2 said no state had to recognise a same-sex marriage from another state.
- Section 3 defined “marriage” and “spouse” for every federal law as only a union of a man and a woman.
Section 3 affected more than a thousand federal laws, from income tax and Social Security to immigration, veterans’ benefits and federal employee health cover.

The state patchwork
With marriage closed at federal level, states went in different directions. Many passed their own bans, often in their constitutions. Others created new statuses.
- Civil unions gave couples all the state-law rights of marriage under another name. Vermont created them in 2000. Illinois followed when Governor Pat Quinn signed a civil union law on 31 January 2011, effective 1 June 2011; the Illinois Department of Insurance explained how it applied to health cover. Hawaii, where the story began, passed civil unions in 2011, effective 1 January 2012.
- Domestic partnerships gave a narrower set of rights. Wisconsin’s registry was created in the state budget that Governor Jim Doyle signed on 29 June 2009. It opened on 3 August 2009 and gave registered couples 43 rights, including hospital visitation and inheritance, as MPR News reported. The University of Wisconsin noted the same budget added partner health insurance for state employees.
- Marriage arrived state by state from 2004: Massachusetts, then Connecticut, Iowa, Vermont, New Hampshire and DC by 2010. See our articles on the Iowa ruling and DC’s marriage law.

Life under Section 3
For married same-sex couples, Section 3 meant a double life. They filed state taxes as married and federal taxes as single. Employer health cover for a spouse counted as taxable income. A surviving spouse could not receive Social Security survivor benefits and could face estate tax that an opposite-sex spouse would not. A US citizen could not sponsor a foreign spouse for a green card.
These gaps shaped the politics of the time. In June 2009 the Justice Department filed a brief defending DOMA in a California case, and campaigners, including the then president of the Human Rights Campaign, wrote to the president objecting to its arguments. During the 2009 and 2010 health care debate, advocates pushed for provisions ending the tax on partner health benefits and recognising LGBT health needs; most were not included in the final law.
The legal attack on DOMA
The first Respect for Marriage Act, to repeal DOMA, was introduced in Congress in September 2009, but it did not pass. Challenges in court went further. In July 2010 a federal judge in Massachusetts ruled Section 3 unconstitutional in two cases. In February 2011 the Obama administration announced it would no longer defend Section 3 in court, though it would continue to enforce it; a House legal group stepped in to defend it.
The decisive case was brought by Edith Windsor, who had to pay more than $360,000 in federal estate tax after the death of her wife, Thea Spyer. On 26 June 2013 the Supreme Court ruled 5 to 4 in United States v. Windsor that Section 3 violated the Fifth Amendment’s guarantee of equal liberty. Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote the majority opinion. Federal agencies then began recognising same-sex marriages.

Obergefell and the end of the patchwork
Windsor left Section 2 in place, so states could still refuse to marry or recognise same-sex couples. After a wave of lower court rulings, the Supreme Court decided Obergefell v. Hodges on 26 June 2015, again 5 to 4 with Justice Kennedy writing. It held that the Fourteenth Amendment requires every state to license and recognise same-sex marriages. The University of Nebraska’s legal history project places the ruling in this longer story.

The Respect for Marriage Act, 2022
DOMA stayed on the books, unenforceable, until 2022. After the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in June 2022, a concurring opinion suggested revisiting other precedents, and Congress moved to protect marriage in statute. The Respect for Marriage Act was signed on 13 December 2022. It repealed DOMA, requires the federal government to recognise any marriage valid where it was performed, and requires states to recognise marriages from other states. It does not require states to issue licences if Obergefell were ever overturned. Justia’s Verdict called it the end of a bad era.

For the human rights ideas behind these cases, see human rights and LGBT rights.
Key takeaways
- DOMA was signed on 21 September 1996 after a Hawaii court case raised the prospect of same-sex marriage.
- Section 3 denied federal recognition to same-sex marriages; Section 2 let states refuse to recognise them.
- States built a patchwork of marriages, civil unions and domestic partnerships, such as Wisconsin’s 2009 registry and Illinois’s 2011 civil unions.
- Windsor (26 June 2013) struck down Section 3; Obergefell (26 June 2015) required marriage equality nationwide.
- The Respect for Marriage Act repealed DOMA on 13 December 2022.
Common questions
What did the Defense of Marriage Act do?
It defined marriage for federal purposes as only between a man and a woman, and allowed states to refuse to recognise same-sex marriages performed in other states.
When was DOMA struck down?
Its federal definition, Section 3, was struck down in United States v. Windsor on 26 June 2013. The whole law was repealed in December 2022.
What is the difference between a civil union and a domestic partnership?
A civil union usually gives all the state-law rights of marriage under another name. A domestic partnership usually gives a narrower, listed set of rights.
Does the Respect for Marriage Act protect same-sex marriage?
It requires federal and interstate recognition of valid marriages. It does not force a state to issue licences itself if the Supreme Court ever reversed Obergefell.
Who was Edith Windsor?
A New York woman whose challenge to a $363,053 estate tax bill after her wife’s death led the Supreme Court to strike down DOMA’s Section 3.
How we wrote this: This history is based on reference works, court decisions, state agency documents and contemporary news reports. It is a summary for general readers and not legal or tax advice. Last checked November 2026.
Sources
- Britannica: Defense of Marriage Act
- Britannica: Respect for Marriage Act
- Justia Verdict: Congress repeals the Defense of Marriage Act
- University of Nebraska: Teaching legal history, DOMA
- MPR News: Wisconsin same-sex couples register (2009)
- University of Wisconsin: Domestic partner insurance in state budget
- Illinois Department of Insurance: Civil union FAQ
Leave a Reply